10 Nov

How Ethical Is Banana Republic?

NOTE: This brand’s rating is under review and subject to change. The article will be updated soon to reflect any changes in scoring.

Banana Republic is an American brand founded by Mel and Patricia Ziegler in 1978 before being bought by Gap in 1983. The brand now operates as a division of Gap (like Old Navy) and has over 600 stores worldwide. The brand (whose name is notedly controversial) originally sold military surplus, khakis, and “safari clothes” before moving on to workwear and casualwear.

According to a recent report, Banana Republic and other Gap-owned brands have made some progress towards building a sustainable future. But what does that mean exactly? How is Banana Republic impacting the planet, people, and animals?

It’s time we answer the crucial question: how ethical is Banana Republic?

Environmental impact

Banana Republic’s environment rating is “It’s A Start”. The brand uses some eco-friendly materials, including recycled materials, like recycled cotton and nylon. Banana Republic has set a goal to use more sustainable fabrics: for example, it claims that “achieving 100% sustainable cotton by 2023” is 87% completed. However, we found no evidence it minimises textile waste when manufacturing its products.

The brand has also set a science-based target to reduce greenhouse gas emissions generated from its operations and supply chain, but there is no evidence it is on track to meet its target.

Banana Republic received an “A” in the CDP water security questionnaire, and the brand demonstrates leadership in managing water use in its supply chain. The fashion industry is a massive consumer and polluter of our freshwater, so it’s refreshing to see such a big label working towards reducing its water impact.

Labour conditions

Sadly, Banana Republic’s labour rating is “Not Good Enough”. While the brand has taken some commendable steps to reduce its impact on the planet, it still has a long way to go to protect its people.

To start with, none of Banana Republic’s supply chain is certified by labour standards which ensure worker health and safety or other labour rights. And while the brand publishes some information about its suppliers, audits, remediation processes, forced labour, gender equality, and freedom of association, Banana Republic lacks the transparency and action crucial to receiving a higher score here.

Most concerning is that we found no evidence Banana Republic ensures payment of a living wage in its supply chain. And while the American brand discloses policies to protect suppliers in its supply chain from the impacts of COVID-19, said policies do not extend to workers.

Animal welfare

Banana Republic has a basic formal policy to protect animal welfare, and it doesn’t use fur, angora, down, or exotic animal skin. But it still uses leather, wool, and exotic animal hair, and we found no evidence the brand traces any animal products to the first stage of production. This lack of effort is simply “Not Good Enough” in a world where people care more than ever about vegan and cruelty-free fashion.

Overall rating: It’s a start

Despite implementing some good measures to reduce its impact on the environment, Banana Republic has a long way to go to be considered sustainable and ethical. The GAP-owned brand needs to be more transparent about its labour practices and ensure workers in its supply chain are paid a living wage and treated fairly. Banana Republic should also rethink its impact on animals, starting with fully tracing products, and ideally use less (or, even better, zero) animal products.

For all these reasons, Banana Republic is rated “It’s A Start” overall. Note that Good On You ratings consider 100s of issues, and it is not possible to list every relevant issue in a summary of the brand’s performance. For more information, see our How We Rate page and our FAQs.

See the rating.

Good swaps

Sustainable alternatives to Banana Republic

Harvest & Mill

Rated: Good
Harvest & Mill sustainable socks pack in ivory

Harvest & Mill pieces are grown, milled, and sewn exclusively in the US, supporting American organic cotton farmers and local sewing communities. The brand makes socks for men and women, always ensuring they are not dyed or bleached, greatly reducing the use of water, energy, and dye materials. Even better, by cultivating different varieties of cotton, the brand is able to bolster biodiversity, which is essential for ensuring healthy ecosystems and keeping our planet resilient in the face of climate change. Neat!

See the rating.

Shop Harvest & Mill.

Shop Harvest & Mill @ Rêve en Vert.

MATE the Label

Rated: Great

MATE the Label creates clean essentials made with GOTS certified organic fabrics and low-impact dyes. Its goal is to offer women everywhere a clean product that is just as beautiful as it is sustainable. It is proudly female-founded and is predominately operated by women. This US brand also manufactures locally to reduce its carbon footprint. Find the range in inclusive sizes XS-3XL.

See the rating.

Shop MATE the Label.

The Classic T-Shirt Company

Rated: Great

Offers

The Classic T-Shirt Co – Women’s Sweatsuits

By shopping these luxury french terry sweatshirts and pants, you're investing in minimalistic, sustainable staples that will last you for years to come. Exclusive 15% off women's sweatshirts and joggers with code GOOD15. (Ends: 11 DEC)

Checkout code: GOOD15
Shop now

The Classic T-Shirt Co – Women’s T-shirts

Enjoy simple pleasures, like these silky soft organic cotton long, short, and 3/4 sleeve t-shirts that are perfect for layering all year round. Exclusive 15% off women's short, 3/4 and long sleeve t-shirts with code GOOD15. (Ends: 11 DEC)

Checkout code: GOOD15
Shop now

The Classic T-Shirt Co – Men’s Sweatsuits

Discover these sustainable sweatsuits, ethically made in the USA and crafted from certified organic cotton. Designed for comfort and built to last. Exclusive 15% off men's sweatshirts and joggers with code GOOD15. (Ends: 11 DEC)

Checkout code: GOOD15
Shop now

The Classic T-Shirt Co – Men’s T-shirts

Slip into the best Classic T-Shirts, made in California and ethically crafted from high quality, 100% organic cotton. Exclusive 15% off men's short and long sleeve t-shirts with code GOOD15. (Ends: 11 DEC)

Checkout code: GOOD15
Shop now

The Classic T-Shirt Company is a US brand that creates premium tees and ethical t-shirts with luxury and integrity. All of its products are GOTS certified organic cotton and it does not use any animal products. The Classic T-Shirt Company’s range is available in US sizes XS-3XL.

See the rating.

Shop The Classic T-Shirt Company.

Shop The Classic T-Shirt Company @ Urbankissed.

milo+nicki

Rated: Great

milo+nicki makes cruelty-free, ethically-designed, eco-conscious womenswear with Indian & Zambian roots. The US brand uses a high proportion of eco-friendly materials like GOTS certified cotton, and is a leading advocate for better labour rights! Find most of the range in XS-XL.

See the rating.

Shop milo+nicki.

Shop milo+nicki @ Made Trade.

ARIELLE

Rated: Good

ARIELLE is a US-based sustainable apparel label committed to organic, recycled and zero-waste fabrics, local manufacturing, fair-trade supply chain and plastic-free packaging and production. It makes covetable clothes with no compromise to people or planet and carries a size range of XS-L.

See the rating.

Shop ARIELLE.

The R Collective

Rated: Great
women wearing blue the r collective trenches

The R Collective's womenswear collections are made by reusing rescued excess materials from leading luxury brands and reputable manufacturers. The brand uses a high-proportion of eco-friendly materials, which limits the amount of chemicals, water, and wastewater used in production. It also ensures the payment of a living wage in its supply chain, which is why we rated it 'Great'! The garments are offered in two sizes: XS-S and M-L.

See the rating.

Shop The R Collective.

Shop The R Collective @ ourCommonplace.

Editor's note

Feature image via Banana Republic, all other images via brands mentioned. Good On You publishes the world's most comprehensive ratings of fashion brands’ impact on people, the planet and animals. Use the Directory to search more than 3,000 brands. To support our work, we may earn a commission on sales made using our offer codes or affiliate links.

Ethical brand ratings. There’s an app for that.

Wear the change you want to see. Download our app to discover ethical brands and see how your favourites measure up.