shoppers in a mall at christmas
17 Nov
shoppers in a mall at christmas

Fast fashion brands don’t need your gift budget. But small brands do

As Black Friday promotions hit inboxes, it can be easy to judge those offering discounts or shopping the sales. But there is nuance surrounding seasonal gifting and spending, as we explore here.

In a season of overconsumption, there is nuance to be found

Every November, we see the same huge, overproducing, global brands use the festive period to profit further off the exploitation underpinning their supply chains. They push shoppers to add more heavily discounted items to their cart, often with time-bound or scarcity-led marketing messages to drive quick purchasing decisions. And all while they continue taking little action to improve their transparency on key sustainability issues affecting those who actually made all the products on offer.

These big businesses already make millions. They already pump out an astonishing number of products. They don’t need to make any more to survive, and they are responsible for the system of overproduction and overconsumption that results in Black Friday and Cyber Monday (and indeed, the whole Christmas shopping complex).

It certainly merits criticism, but there is a need for nuance here, and this year more than ever. Because while fast fashion brands race to the bottom, many smaller independent businesses make most of their annual revenue in the months around the festive period. Expecting small brands to go dark and stop selling during peak season while they try to get by doesn’t support a sustainable business model in our current society, and it ignores that the onus should be on the biggest brands contributing to the problem.

 

Why small brands need your support more than ever

The last few years have been especially tough for small businesses thanks to the cost of living crisis, fluctuating tariffs, governments backpedalling on sustainability, shoppers having tighter budgets, and numerous other factors. The result is that many brands have shuttered: we’ve seen some of our most-loved, highest-rated brands that were demonstrating a better way to operate having to close due to financial pressures. Brands like this need support throughout the year, and doing so doesn’t mean spending beyond your means or buying more; it just means considering who you buy from when you do have the budget for gifting.

Many small brands do choose to close their websites on Black Friday and Cyber Monday or donate their profits from the period. German brand Dirts, for instance, donates extra money to the workers in its Portuguese factory and organises a party with them. The brand describes it as “A decision against discounts. Not against consumption.”

Even so, shaming small brands who do offer promotions means we’re applying the same expectations we have of big, financially powerful brands to small labels that contribute significantly less to the biggest problems in sustainability, and in many cases are working to improve the industry. These brands need our support more than they need us to boycott purchasing on a specific week of the year.

It’s certainly true that shopping during this season requires a more mindful approach, considering how much we want or need the items we’re being sold, and we’ve published guidance to help you do that. But ultimately, making sweeping critiques of small brands or indeed the shoppers involved only serves to ignore the deeper issues at the heart of the hype.

We’ve already covered why shaming shoppers for buying items in seasonal sales is problematic. We’re in the midst of a cost of living crisis, and as Nadra Nittle argued in Vox in 2018, classism, racism, and sexism are factors behind Black Friday rage-bait. Judging others for what they’re buying overlooks the systemic issues that drive overconsumption in the first place. Worse, it distracts from who’s really responsible: the wealthiest brands who hold the power to change their supply chains and choose not to.

So, if you do have a budget to spend this holiday season and you want to make some considered purchases for items you or your loved ones will value, put it into the small businesses that are doing something by hand, at a small scale, and that are taking action for the planet. For fast fashion brands, your budget is a drop in their bucket of profits. For small brands, it’s how they survive. And unlike something mass-produced, items from independent brands often come with a story of craftsmanship, inspiration, or heritage, which make for a more meaningful gift experience, after all.

Editor's note

Good On You publishes the most transparent sustainability ratings for fashion, beauty and retail. We rate brands on key sustainability issues for people, the planet, and animals. Search our directory to find the latest ratings.

Ethical brand ratings. There’s an app for that.

Wear the change you want to see. Download our app to discover ethical brands and see how your favourites measure up.

The latest intel in your inbox

Join more than 100,000 readers, from young shoppers to corporate sustainability managers, who read our newsletters.

Welcome to good on you.
Let’s create a cleaner future together.

Sign up for updates. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.